Why Are Children's Books for Ages 9-12 Being Banned?

As of March 2024, the Evanston Public Library noted 64 cases of book bans, challenges, or restrictions. These events occurred across 18 states. The focus of these bans is on children's books for those aged 9-12. This trend has brought censorship and controversial themes into significant debate.

"Drama" by Raina Telgemeier, "The Watsons Go to Birmingham" by Christopher Paul Curtis, and "Melissa" by Alex Gino are some key titles facing bans. These bans relate to LGBTQIA+ content and representation, as well as issues such as "inappropriate language and violence". Clearly, the lack of access to varied viewpoints is a concern. These issues prompt important conversations about what is truly age-appropriate literature and the value of open discourse on sensitive subjects.

The debate over what's okay for kids to read is getting intense. We're starting to see more books being banned or challenged, especially among the 9-12 age group. Author Malinda Lo shared that her books faced bans in 64 cases over 18 states by March 2024. Texas, Iowa, Florida, and Virginia have had the most cases.

Statistics on Challenged and Banned Books

Malinda Lo's "Last Night at the Telegraph Club" was hit hard, with 50 bans across 15 states. Books like the "Harry Potter" series, "Roll of Thunder, Hear My Cry" by Mildred D. Taylor, and "The Lorax" by Dr. Seuss have also been challenged. These books tackle magic, racism, and environmental issues, showing a worrying trend in censorship of children's literature.

Examples of Popular Titles Under Fire

Books across many genres are facing bans for the 9-12 age group. This includes "Drama" by Raina Telgemeier, and "A Wrinkle in Time" by Madeleine L'Engle. "Worm Loves Worm" by J.J. Austrian, "And Tango Makes Three" by Justin Richardson, and "Harry Potter" by J.K. Rowling have been banned too. Many argue these books are too much for kids, too mature or too controversial.

Some books are being banned or challenged for their content on LGBTQIA+ representation, gender identity, and depictions of racism and social issues. For instance, "Drama" by Raina Telgemeier, "Melissa" by Alex Gino, and "Prince & Knight" by Daniel Haack are facing criticism. This is because they talk about LGBTQIA+ characters and themes.

LGBTQIA+ Representation and Gender Identity

Content on LGBTQIA+ in kids' books is causing quite a stir. Some parents and groups believe these topics are not right for kids. Yet, others stress how vital it is for children to see themselves in books and learn about diversity.

Depictions of Racism and Social Issues

Books that deal with racism in kids' lit, like "The Watsons Go to Birmingham" and "Something Happened in our Town", have also met opposition. Some say they are divisive or villainize the police. The issue here is whether these topics are okay for children between 9 and 12.

Many books banned or challenged for ages 9-12 include a variety of genres. They range from graphic novels to classics. "Drama" and "A Wrinkle in Time" are examples. Other banned books are "Worm Loves Worm", "And Tango Makes Three", and "Harry Potter". Concerns about these books include if they're too mature. Some worry they might be controversial for this age group.

"The books being banned or challenged for children ages 9-12 often cover LGBTQIA+ topics, gender identity, and themes like racism."

The debate about censorship in middle grade literature continues. It sparks discussions on how to protect kids without limiting their learning.

The argument over what age-appropriate literature is centers on kids aged 9-12. Some say books with LGBTQIA+ themes, depictions of racism, or sexual content are not right for them. But others believe kids should learn about these topics in a way that suits their age. This helps in thinking and talking about important matters.

Differing Views on What's Suitable for Tweens

People disagree on what's suitable for tweens because they see literature's role in kids' growth differently. Those for book bans think some content is too much for kids this age. However, those against bans think it's good for kids to see a wide range of ideas and issues.

Importance of Context and Nuanced Discussion

Many say that how we approach complex topics in books is crucial. They argue that instead of banning books, adults should help kids understand and discuss the themes. This approach turns challenging content into a chance for meaningful learning and talking.

Still, deciding on age-appropriate content for tweens is tough. This is because this issue has many sides and is not easy to solve.

The debate over banning books for kids 9-12 touches on censorship and the right to freedom of expression. People are concerned because they believe removing books stops kids from learning about different viewpoints. They think kids should have the chance to handle tough topics in a safe space.

Many view the push against book banning with worry. They fear it could limit how kids think and explore new ideas. Not letting kids read about censorship in children's literature or freedom of expression might make it hard for them to learn about life's big questions.

The issue of book banning is making everyone talk. We need to empower parents and educators. They should help kids think for themselves. This is better than completely banning books.

Fostering Critical Thinking and Open Dialogue

Educators pick books that kids can understand for each age. They guide kids gently through tough topics. Meanwhile, parents read with kids, making sure they process it correctly. This team effort helps kids learn to think and decide on their own.

Guidance on Selecting Age-Appropriate Literature

Blocking kids from books is not the best way. Parents and educators should choose wisely. They can pick age-appropriate books that teach valuable lessons. This way, kids learn to think for themselves in a safe setting.

The trend of banning and challenging children's books for ages 9-12 is worrying. It makes us think about censorship, free speech, and the role parents and teachers play. They help shape what's right for kids to read. Yet, just taking books away from kids isn't the answer.

Instead, we need to encourage talking and thinking. We should pick books that deal with tough topics carefully and wisely. This helps kids learn to think for themselves and understand the world better.

With parents and teachers working together, we make sure kids can read all sorts of books. They learn to see different views and think critically. This doesn't just help kids' reading. It also helps them grow into adults who understand the world deeply and care about others.

What is the growing trend of book banning for children's books for ages 9-12?

Books for kids ages 9-12 are facing bans or challenges across the U.S. This is mainly due to their themes and content being seen as controversial. For example, books like "Drama" by Raina Telgemeier, "The Watsons Go to Birmingham" by Christopher Paul Curtis, and "Melissa" by Alex Gino are often challenged.

What are some statistics on challenged and banned books for this age group?

By March 2024, Malinda Lo's books were restricted 64 times in 18 states across the U.S. Places like Texas, Iowa, Florida, and Virginia have seen many bans. Her book "Last Night at the Telegraph Club" was banned or challenged in 50 cases across 15 states. Other well-known books that faced challenges are the "Harry Potter" series, "Roll of Thunder, Hear My Cry" by Mildred D. Taylor, and "The Lorax" by Dr. Seuss.

What are some examples of popular titles that have been banned or challenged for this age group?

"Drama" by Raina Telgemeier, "Melissa" by Alex Gino, and "Prince & Knight" by Daniel Haack have been banned or challenged. This is because of their LGBTQIA+ themes and characters. Books like "The Watsons Go to Birmingham" by Christopher Paul Curtis and "Something Happened in our Town" have faced criticism for addressing racism.

What are the controversial themes that are sparking backlash in children's books for ages 9-12?

The banned or challenged books often touch on LGBTQIA+ issues, gender identity, and racism. These themes are central to the debate about book banning. The argument is around what kids can read at this age.

What types of children's books for ages 9-12 are being banned or challenged?

Many different kinds of books are being banned. This includes everything from graphic novels like "Drama" to old classics like "A Wrinkle in Time." Even picture books like "Worm Loves Worm" and "And Tango Makes Three" have been banned. The popular "Harry Potter" series has also faced restrictions.

What is the debate around age-appropriate content for children ages 9-12?

There's a big debate over what's okay for kids aged 9-12 to read. Some think books about LGBTQIA+ issues or racism are not right. Others believe these topics can help kids learn and think.

What are the concerns about censorship and freedom of expression in the book banning movement?

Stopping books means kids miss out on different ideas and discussions. It's important for kids to think critically and make their own choices about what they read. This is better than just not letting them read certain books.

How can parents and educators navigate the challenges of book banning?

The focus should be on helping kids think and talk about tough topics. Selecting books that deal with issues responsibly is key. This gives kids a chance to hear different views and learn to think for themselves.

• https://www.malindalo.com/blog/2024/3/8/my-books-keep-getting-banned-an-update
• https://www.epl.org/booklist/shhhh-these-kids-books-have-been-banned-or-challenged/